News

CASE SUMMARIES 10/1/2026 – 10/31/2026

            PENNSYLVANIA WORKERS’ COMPENSATION
CASE SUMMARIES

10/1/2026 – 10/31/2026

JUDICIAL DISCRETION
REASONED DECISION

Glenn Gough v. UGI Utilities, Inc. (WCAB)
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania – Unpublished Memorandum Opinion
Decided: October 27, 2026

Issue:
Whether the WCJ erred in rejecting Claimant’s testimony and failed to make a reasoned decision?

Background:
Claimant filed a claim petition alleging that he sustained a work injury.  Employer filed a Notice of Compensation Denial, which denied that the injuries were work related.  The WCJ issued a decision denying the claim petition. The WCJ generally rejected Claimant’s testimony as not credible, in part based on his demeanor during in-person hearings.  Claimant appealed to the Board, which affirmed.

Holding:
The WCJ’s credibility determinations were not arbitrary and capricious or so fundamentally dependent on a misapprehension of material facts, or so otherwise flawed, as to render them irrational.  Further, Employer’s expert’s testimony is not inconsistent or contradictory. The decision was reasoned as it allowed for adequate review by the appellate courts under the applicable review standards.  The WCJ summarized testimony and objectively explained her credibility determinations.  There is no basis for overturning the WCJ’s credibility determinations and the WC properly relied on her own observations of Claimant’s demeanor.  Claimant’s argument that the WCJ capriciously disregarded uncontroverted evidence has no merit. Claimant’s evidence was not uncontroverted. Furthermore, the WCJ did not capriciously disregard Claimant’s evidence. The WCJ’s express consideration and rejection of Claimant’s evidence, by definition, is not capricious disregard.   The WCJ did not err in rejecting claimant’s expert’s opinion of the work-related nature of Claimant’s carpal tunnel and cubital tunnel syndrome, given the reliance on Claimant’s self-reported use of vibratory tools, which the WCJ deemed not credible. The WCJ provided several reasons for rejecting claimant’s expert’s testimony and opinions, and these were all based on substantial evidence of record.  This satisfies the reasoned decision requirement in Section 422(a).
Affirmed.

SUBSEQUENT PETITIONS

RES JUDICATA AND COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL

Patrick Murray v. City of Philadelphia (WCAB)
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania – Unpublished Memorandum Opinion
Decided: October 15, 2026

Issue:
Whether the claim petition was barred by res judicata and collateral estoppel?

Background:
Claimant worked as a police officer for the City of Philadelphia. He was diagnosed with COVID-19 and reported his diagnosis to his supervisor. Employer designated Claimant’s time off work as “E-Time,” or “excused time,” during which he was paid his full salary without using his accrued sick or vacation leave. The E-Time payments ended a few months later, at which point Claimant began using his accrued sick leave.  Claimant filed reinstatement and penalty petitions, alleging that his COVID-19 diagnosis was a work injury. Employer then “unilaterally terminated benefits after accepting the claim for COVID with the payment of wages in lieu of benefits as a matter of law.”  The WCJ denied both petitions. The WCJ found that Employer’s payments made under the E-Time designation did not constitute an acknowledgement that the employee’s COVID-19 diagnosis was work-related. Rather, the E-Time designation applied to employees who could not work for any reason. The WCJ discredited Claimant’s testimony that he gave timely notice to Employer that his COVID-19 diagnosis was work-related.  The Claimant later filed a Claim petition for COVID, alleging, as he did in his Reinstalment petition, that he contracted the disease in the course and scope of his employment as a police officer for Employer.  The WCJ denied this as well.  The Board affirmed.

Holding:
Technical res judicata and collateral estoppel are related, yet distinct principles of the doctrine known as res judicata. Under technical res judicata, a final judgment on the merits precludes a future lawsuit on the same cause of action. Collateral estoppel, or issue preclusion, acts to foreclose litigation in a subsequent action where issues of law or fact were actually litigated and necessary to a previous final judgment.  The instant claim petition is barred by the doctrine of technical res judicata. The “thing sued upon or for” in Claimant’s reinstatement petition and claim petition is his entitlement to workers’ compensation benefits for his COVID-19 diagnosis. As to the second element, the identity of the causes of action, Claimant has already litigated his claim for compensation benefits in the reinstatement proceeding and now seeks to re-litigate that question but in a claim petition. Recasting the nomenclature of the request from a reinstatement petition to a claim petition did not change the cause of action. Finally, the parties to both the reinstatement petition and the claim petition are the same, and no issue has been raised as to their capacities to sue or be sued. Thus, the four elements of technical res judicata are met. In the alternative, the claim petition is barred by collateral estoppel because it has been adjudicated that Claimant did not provide timely notice to Employer of his alleged work-related injury.   Employer’s payment of E-Time benefits was not intended to constitute the payment of wages in lieu of workers’ compensation benefits. The WCJ discredited Claimant’s testimony that he notified Employer of his alleged work injury, which was offered to prove that Employer intended the E-Time benefits as workers’ compensation payments. Rather, the WCJ found that Claimant “reported a serious and emerging health issue to a supervisor in an effort to protect the health and safety of other police officers and the general public. Claimant and the Employer primarily focused their attention on impeding the spread of the virus rather than discussing how an individual may or may not have contracted the virus.  Claimant does not argue that he lacked knowledge that his COVID-19 diagnosis was work related. To the contrary, he testified in the reinstatement proceeding that a month after he tested positive for COVID-19, he told his supervisor that he believed he contracted the virus at work. The 120-day notice period started to run once Claimant knew or should have known the work-relatedness of his injury, which deadline Claimant did not meet.  The issue of Claimant’s notice to Employer was decided in the reinstatement proceeding and is identical to the issue of notice presented in the instant proceeding; there was a final judgment on the reinstatement petition; Claimant was a party to the reinstatement petition proceeding; and he had a full and fair opportunity to litigate the notice issue in that proceeding. All elements of collateral estoppel are met. As such, Claimant is now estopped from arguing that he gave Employer timely notice under Section 311 of the Act in the context of the claim petition.  Claimant’s claim petition is barred by technical res judicata and collateral estoppel.
Affirmed.


COURSE AND SCOPE OF EMPLOYMENT
BURDEN OF PROOF – HEART ATTACK

Angel Torres v. The Giant Company (WCAB)
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania – Unpublished Memorandum Opinion
Decided: October 26, 2026

Issue:
Whether, because Claimant’s work duties obviously caused his heart attack, he was not required to present medical evidence?

Background:
Claimant was a working supervisor of a small demolition crew, and he also demolished walls by hand or crowbar.  Claimant’s own history stated that his chest pain occurred before the drywall removal.  And that, before his shift started, Claimant had episodes of chest pain, which also radiated into his neck and his jaw, shortness of breath, and arm weakness.  His later testimony contradicted this history.  On the date of the accident while working, Claimant started getting pain in his chest.  Claimant did not finish his shift and drove himself to a nearby hospital.  A few months later, Claimant filed a claim petition describing his injury as a heart attack from working.  Employer denied liability.  The WCJ denied Claimant’s petition. The Board affirmed, reasoning that the causal relationship “was not obvious” and thus required medical evidence.

Holding:
The mere fact that Claimant experienced symptoms of a heart attack at work, even while performing his work activities, does not render those symptoms or the underlying cause of the symptoms work-related.  Any pain experienced by the claimant at work was not the actual heart attack, but simply a manifestation of the preexisting heart disease.  Claimant’s testimony alone did not suffice, and he needed to present expert medical testimony to establish that his work activities caused his mid-shift heart attack. Claimant’s lay testimony of mid-shift chest pain does not, by itself, prove causation without the need for expert testimony. The WCJ had discredited his causation testimony and had credited expert testimony that Claimant’s heart attack occurred before his shift. Without an obvious causal connection, Claimant needed unequivocal expert testimony. The WCJ discredited Claimant’s medical expert connecting Claimant’s heart attack to his work. Employer’s expert attributed that heart attack to Claimant’s smoking and history of high blood pressure and cholesterol.  Claimant’s risk factors undermine any presumption of an obvious causal connection between the work incident and Claimant’s heart attack. Claimant did not provide credited unequivocal expert testimony connecting his heart attack to his work.  It boils down to whether Claimant suffered a heart attack before or during his overnight shift. The credited medical evidence established that Claimant had a heart attack before his overnight shift.  Claimant’s heart attack followed prior chest pain.  Although Claimant had denied prior chest pain, the WCJ discredited his testimony in favor of Employer’s medical expert’s testimony. This expert opined that Claimant’s heart attack occurred before his shift. Thus, based on the credited testimony, Claimant failed to prove an obvious causal connection between his work and his heart attack and, therefore, could not prove compensability.
Affirmed.

LABOR MARKET SURVEY MODIFICATION
EMPLOYER’S BURDEN – OPEN AND AVAILABLE

Steven Waldman v. Limerick Fire Department (WCAB)
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania – Unpublished Memorandum Opinion
Decided: October 21, 2026

Issue:
Whether the WCJ’s suspension of the claimant’s benefits was based upon substantial       evidence?

Background:
Claimant sustained a work injury when he slipped and fell while working for Employer as a volunteer firefighter. Employer filed its Suspension Petition and a Petition for Modification of Benefits asserting work was generally available for Claimant within his medical and vocational restrictions based on a labor market survey (LMS).  The WCJ found the testimony of Employer’s medical expert, with respect to Claimant’s physical capabilities, to be credible. The WCJ found Claimant’s job restrictions credible after considering the evidence.  Moreover, the WCJ deemed the vocational counselor’s testimony regarding Claimant’s earning capacity to be credible, as she testified to all necessary elements of her preparation of the LMS and earning power assessment, including having confirmed that there was no work available with Employer within his work restrictions.  The WCJ noted Claimant had the opportunity to go out on his own and find a job within his physical capabilities himself and has not done so.  Accordingly, the WCJ suspended Claimant’s temporary total disability benefits as of the date of the LMS.  Claimant appealed the WCJ’s Decision to the Board, and the Board affirmed.

Holding:
Employer’s medical expert’s testimony, in its entirety, reveals an unequivocal opinion of Claimant’s ability to perform medium-duty work. The positions identified did not exceed Claimant’s physical capabilities.  The WCJ found Claimant could perform medium-duty work. Additionally, the vocational witness, who the WCJ found credible, testified that she contacted the employers to establish the work duties for each of the Positions. She also indicated the Positions were open and available and suitable for Claimant’s physical capabilities, as outlined by Employer’s medical expert.  Employer presented testimony that the witness contacted the employers regarding the available positions and sent the referral letters to Claimant regarding the positions. While the witness did not testify regarding the continued availability of the jobs beyond that date, Claimant testified that he received the referral letters and applied to all six of the identified positions. Claimant’s testimony supports the WCJ’s finding that the positions were open and available when he applied. There was no indication in the record that Claimant was prevented from applying for any of the identified jobs or that Claimant was not offered a position because the jobs had already been filled before his applications. Employer met its burden of proving, through competent and substantial evidence, that Claimant was capable of performing medium-duty work, and it identified open and available jobs within Claimant’s vocational and physical capabilities. Employer demonstrated an increase in Claimant’s earning power under Section 306(b)(2) of the Act, and, therefore, the WCJ’s grant of Employer’s Suspension Petition was not in error.
Affirmed.

Dissent – Renée Cohn Jubelirer, President Judge, dissented primarily based upon her opinion that the Employer failed to meet its burden of proving that it identified jobs within Claimant vocational and physical capabilities that remained open and available until such time as he had a reasonable opportunity to apply.


PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE REVIEW

Senate Bill 1094.
A while ago, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, House L&I Committee, voted on what was then designated as HB 183. This Bill expands access to workers compensation disfigurement benefits by increasing the duration of eligibility from up to 275 weeks to a new level of up to 400 weeks, extending the benefit to the entire body, and not just to the head, face and neck, and allowing these benefits to be paid simultaneously with indemnity benefits.  The bill was passed by the House on April 7, 2025, and has now been referred to the Senate Labor & Industry Committee.  It is now under Senate Bill 1094 and has yet to be reported from the committee. 

Other Selected Proposed Legislation of Interest in the 2025-2026 session

The following selected amendments to the PA Workers’ Compensation Act have been proposed, but as of this date are in early stages, and no formal vote as been held, and these are referred to their respective L&I Committees:

In the Senate: (these are still in committee)

Senate Bill 801 – Seeks to clarify that the Act provides the exclusive remedy for any injury or disease that may arise out of hazardous occupational exposure, whether the disease is compensable or not.

Senate Bill 894 – Seeks to clarify the “Independent Contractor Classification.”

Senate Bill 1151 – Removal of Clinical Practice Requirement for Physicians Performing Impairment Rating Evaluations (IREs).

Senate Bill 1215 – Addressing Excessive Costs for Prescription Topical Drugs in Workers’ Compensation.  Reported as “committed” effective June 2026.

House Bill 2049 – Raising Workers’ Compensation Burial Benefits. (Sent to the senate on June 18, 2026)

House Bill 2087 – Ensuring that volunteer firefighters and EMTs are covered under workers’ compensation when injured during fundraising activities. (Sent to the senate on April 2026)

Approved by the Senate on March 24, 2026 – Sent to the House and now referred out of Committee as amended in April 2026.

Senate Bill 1053 – Seeks to clarify workers compensation coverage for EMS Volunteers.

In the House Only: (these are still in committee)

House Bill 1766 – Workers’ Compensation Coverage of Prescribed Medical Cannabis

(Formerly HB 1079).

House Bill 1998 – Modernizing and Improving Medical Treatment in Workers’ Compensation


NEW JERSEY WORKERS’ COMPENSATION
CASE SUMMARIES

10/1/2026 – 10/31/2026

NATURE AND EXTENT OF PERMANENT INJURY

Lawhorn v. County of Monmouth
Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division
A-3070-24; 2026 WL 3072024
Decided: 10/14/2026

Background:
Petitioner Jason Lawhorn injured his back during the course and scope of employment with Respondent, County of Monmouth. The petitioner had a prior back injury where he received a partial compensation award of 22.5% for a lumbar injury. Prior to this accident, the petitioner reopened his claim which resulted in an increased award of 31% permanent partial disability.

As a result of the injury with County of Monmouth, the judge entered judgment for 55% partial disability with a credit of 31% from the prior work-related injury. Respondent argued the petitioner’s complaints related to both injuries significantly overlapped. The Judge found while there was overlap, the petitioner’s testimony supports a material and significant deterioration in his condition after the accident with Respondent. The Judge further found the petitioner’s medical expert more credible.

Holding:
The Court found that the Judge properly determined that the petitioner satisfied the requirements in Perez. There was objective medical evidence supporting the petitioner’s testimony that his functioning had decreased. The Judge further found that Respondent’s accident resulted in more difficulty performing tasks. The petitioner satisfied Perez as there was an appreciable impairment of the ability to work. Further, the Judge made clear that he considered the petitioner’s prior symptoms and limitations and explained why there was a substantial increase in permanency. The Judge’s conclusions were supported by and consistent with competent, relevant and credible evidence.
Affirmed.

NEW JERSEY LEGISLATIVE UPDATE

Assembly Bill 4617
Concerns certain workers’ compensation supplemental benefits and funding method.
Last Action: March 10, 2026 – Introduced, Referred to Assembly Labor Committee

Senate Bill 3984/A1023
Requires workers’ compensation, PIP, and health insurance coverage for the medical use of cannabis under certain circumstances.

Last Action: March 19, 2026 – Introduced in the Senate, Referred to Senate Commerce Committee

Senate Bill 3342
Increases statutory mandatory retirement age for Supreme Court Justices, Superior Court Judges, Tax Court Judges, Administrative Law Judges, and Workers’ Compensation Judges from 70 to 75.

Last Action: February 5, 2026 – Introduced in the Senate, Referred to Senate Judiciary Committee

Senate Bill 3571/A3548
Provides certain volunteer and other workers with maximum compensation benefit for workers’ compensation claim regardless of outside employment.

Last Action: May 7, 2026 – Reported and Referred to Assembly State and Local Government Committee

Assembly Bill 4827
Requires Administrative Law Judges to be enrolled in Workers Compensation Judges Part of PERS.

Last Action: May 4, 2026 – Introduced, Referred to Assembly State and Local Government Committee

Senate Bill 4381
Exempts election worker compensation from taxation.

Last Action: June 1, 2026 – Introduced in the Senate, Referred to Senate State Government, Wagering, Tourism & Historic Preservation Committee